In another defense win, the Court of Appeals in Salt Lake City v. Bench upheld the trial court's decision to suppress the evidence obtained following a traffic stop of the defendant's vehicle. The City argued that the stop of the defendant's vehicle was proper where there was a tip from the defendant's ex-wife stating that the defendant had transported his children while intoxicated. In addition, the City relied on the officer's observations once he located the vehicle. The officer did not observe any traffic violations, but insisted that traveling 10 mph below the speed limit and signalling for five seconds (instead of the requisite 3 seconds) were indicative of overly cautious (and thus impaired) driving.
The Court of Appeals rejects the City's position that the officer's stop was justified by reasonable suspicion. The court first notes that the tip provided little detail and any corroboration was limited to innocuous observations. Similarly, the court gives less weight to the tip because of the fact that it came from the defendant's ex-wife, citing a number of cases in support of the proposition that such a tip is less reliable since it may come from someone bearing ill will or malice toward the former spouse/partner.
In addition, the court rejected the assertion that cautious driving gave the officer reasonable suspicion. As the court noted, "[p]rudent driving--going slower than the posted speed limit in a residential area and signaling for a couple of seconds longer than the statutory minimum--is simply not suspicious. It is commendable."
All in all, the decision in Bench provides ample fodder for defense counsel regarding tips and corroboration of innocent details. Similarly, counsel faced with the familiar contention that your client was driving too safely ought to use this decision to dispel any suspicions of impaired driving.
Showing posts with label reasonable suspicion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reasonable suspicion. Show all posts
Sunday, January 27, 2008
Tuesday, January 15, 2008
Tenth Circuit Provides Oblique Invitation for Suppression Challenges
While the Tenth Circuit's decision today in United States v. Martinez rejected the defendants' arguments about the constitutionality of an officer's stop of their vehicle, there is a glimmer (albeit ever so slight) of hope.
The defendants in Martinez contended that an officer improperly stopped the defendants' vehicle based on alleged license plate violation. The defendants were travelling through Utah in a vehicle without a front license plate; the vehicle did have a proper rear plate, however. The UHP Trooper pulled over the vehicle based on his belief that California law required a front license plate. The Tenth Circuit dismissed the defendants' argument that California law requires only one license plate, and found that the Trooper had reasonable suspicion to effectuate a traffic stop. In an interesting footnote, however, the panel noted that "[d]efendants do not challenge the authority of a Utah police officer to stop a vehicle for violation of an out-of-state equipment requirement... We thus have no occasion to decide whether Utah law permits law enforcement officers to enforce violations of out-of-state license plate requirements."
Admittedly, the footnote does not actually state that the argument is compelling or with some force, but it does provide the opportunity to make this argument in the district court or the Tenth Circuit. As far as litigating in the Tenth Circuit is concerned, the mere fact that an argument is not completely foreclosed by existing precedent is cause for excitement.
The defendants in Martinez contended that an officer improperly stopped the defendants' vehicle based on alleged license plate violation. The defendants were travelling through Utah in a vehicle without a front license plate; the vehicle did have a proper rear plate, however. The UHP Trooper pulled over the vehicle based on his belief that California law required a front license plate. The Tenth Circuit dismissed the defendants' argument that California law requires only one license plate, and found that the Trooper had reasonable suspicion to effectuate a traffic stop. In an interesting footnote, however, the panel noted that "[d]efendants do not challenge the authority of a Utah police officer to stop a vehicle for violation of an out-of-state equipment requirement... We thus have no occasion to decide whether Utah law permits law enforcement officers to enforce violations of out-of-state license plate requirements."
Admittedly, the footnote does not actually state that the argument is compelling or with some force, but it does provide the opportunity to make this argument in the district court or the Tenth Circuit. As far as litigating in the Tenth Circuit is concerned, the mere fact that an argument is not completely foreclosed by existing precedent is cause for excitement.
Labels:
reasonable suspicion,
suppression,
Tenth Circuit
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)